- Newton's Third Law of Motion states that any time a force acts from one object to another, there is an equal force acting back on the original object. If you pull on a rope, therefore, the rope is pulling back on you as well
The latex bounces, how wil then provide pressure relief and support? May be some support but pressure relief - I don't think so. So latex does not work. Also latex is Not comfortable since it has bounce and PUSHBACK. This message was modified Dec 2, 2011 by Joed
|
You don't have a vendetta do you ? THat being said, I decided to ditch my latex core (from an old mattress where it was married with cheap pu eggcrate) in favor of some high-quality (hopefully, time will tell) p/u from FBM. I vastly prefer it. Hwoever, I still like a latex topper.
|
|
If memory foam does not provide push back than how does it provide support? What exactly do you mean latex does not work? Can you clarify what a mattress needs to accomplish before it works? You have basically said that memory foam does not support because it doesn't push back, and latex does not provide pressure relief because it does push back. Using this logic it is impossible for ANY bed to do both. Although I should refrain, I feel the need to post this...I have no self control these days: |
In other words, all mattresses push back an equal amount of force on your body. This force is equal to the weight of your body pushing down on the mattress, the amount of pressure has to do with how much contact area there is to spread this force out more evenly over your body. For example when you sleep on your side, your shoulders and hips sink into the bed greatly creating more pressure on these areas than on other body parts. When sleeping on the same bed on your back, you will have less pressure overall due to having more surface area to spread the same weight out. Some beds are more conforming than others, this is defined in part by how elastic a bed is...latex foam is elastic and flexible, hence it is pressure relieving compared to a rigid firm mattress...unless of course you are sleeping on a super firm latex mattress. Memory foam is pliable and cradling; but ultimately still pushes back with the same total amount of force once it has adjusted; it just feels different and your posture may be slightly different than it is on a latex mattress. |
I also read about pushback at this forum. It is not the same feeling I got with poly foam. The latex is bouncy and it is rubber. Try sleeping on rubber. It pinches even though it may be the softest. that pinch is pushback I guess. Very uncomfortable. If latex was so good we would have latex stores everywhere and latex beds would be carried at major retail stores too. Reality is here mattress firm and mattress giant have stopped carrying all latex beds they had. Because they told me they don't sell. Well they would sell if they were any goood wouldnt they? If latex was so great all stores would be carrying latex beds. But reality is almost no retail stores do. And it is pretty big hasle for most people to buy mattresses over the internet. people want to lay down on the beds in a store and feel them. Well there are no latex mattresses here. Because as I said if they were so good stores would carry them. But they don't. This message was modified Dec 3, 2011 by Joed
|
When someone say "this does not work for me" (as I myself have done recently writing about my experience of a latex core and my preference for p/u), that is reasonable. When someone makes a blanket statement like "latex does not work" and "latex is not comfortable", it seems a little odd. What IS nonsense is to assume that whatever is true for one person is true for all people - especially on something as personal as a bed. This message was modified Dec 3, 2011 by RustyShackleford
|
|
Latex does pushback and it pushes back hard. I have had 3 latex mattresses, the firm ones and the softest ones and so I am talking from experience. May be you are "one" of those oddballs that like the pushback from a mattress. 99% of people don't. Most people do not find pushback "conmfortable" This message was modified Dec 3, 2011 by roy1
|
2 inch of celsion latex upon 1 inch of dunlop latex upon 2 inch of talalaly latex and all this 6 inch sits atop a 8 inch base of some fancy name they call "soy foam" I slept on it for 30 minutes and it seemed soft. Perhaps all night sleeping would be different. I don't know since I have had enough of latex. It did not work for me after 3 mattresses. The firm ones and the soft ones all had pushbacks. The feeling is totally unpleasant. It may support but it does not provide presure relief. This message was modified Dec 3, 2011 by roy1
|
So you are saying that a fast responding mattress is uncomfortable. So springs and latex don't work for 99% of people, I would say that overall most surveys and studies would disagree with you. So the only comfortable mattress for those 99% would be what? Memory foam because it is slow response and does not have the 'push back'? I think I need to stop posting here...because I am having a hard time absorbing these ridiculous blanket statements...you offer no real advice, you offer no solutions...you simply point the finger at one product which has worked for many people and say 'it's no good'. |
You seem easily provoked, sorry for feding into that. But I mainly want to learn. So I'm actually glad to hear that I'm not nuts for not liking the latex core (that I pulled from a mattress of latex+eggcrate). I just hope the p/u I replaced it with lasts awhile; but it's cheap enough to replace fiarly often I guess. I still think I like the latex topper. This message was modified Dec 3, 2011 by RustyShackleford
|
I wouldn't see chain stores carrying all-latex mattresses because I think they would tend to be quite heavy for their size and fold over too much when trying to move. It is more difficult to deal with a zipper covered, layered latex mattress than one that is, well, one-piece. Of course, the layered latex mattresses have their advantages of split sides and being able to restack and change firmnesses. I was pretty surprised with what happened when I put the 3 layer talalay onto its matching pine slat foundation. There was nothing else I was doing that would have caused my right shoulder to hurt so much, but after 1 night on the config, I ran out to buy 'a mattress pad'.... which was really an attempt to make the bed softer and more pressure relieving. I knew I was at a point where experimenting with layer exchanges to try 'n make it work on that pine slat foundation would be almost intolerable. I was on my 4th mattress at that point already. So, I put the all latex back on 'box spring in one room and the TP Cloud in the other. Slept a couple nights on each for a week or so. Took a while but was crystal clear - I much preferred the TP Cloud and believe me, no lie, nothing to gain financially, I still do. Worth every penny of the $1600 for my right shoulder. One last thougt - I was VERY skeptical of Tempurpedic for 5 months and trying 4 other mattresses before getting it. I only wish I could take back the time and have bought it initially, but how would I have known? Guess I had to go through that process. This message was modified Dec 3, 2011 by slpngoc
|
I think that the best way to understand any of the foams or springs (in regards to push back) would be that if you are pushing against something it has to push back (which someone posted in the very beginning). The problem with most mattress salespeople is that we are trained to sell an item and not a science... or physics. The truth is, when you are trying to find a sleep system that will allow you to sink where you need to (hips and shoulders) but be supported up where you need it (waist, lower back). Latex, when trying to find the right one for you, needs to allow your hips and shoulders to sink while still holding the small ofyour back up to keep your alignment correct. Too many times we "buy" the speech of the salesman (of which I am one) and do not pay attention to the way our back feels... or we don't spend enough time testing the beds that feel good at first. To top it off, we find all of the posts and reviews that are negative and completely write off a possible solution. I suggest that the method of support (coils, pocketed coils, latex, visco, etc.) while having their respective positive and negative attributes can be truly tested for you ONLY BY YOU. I use this method in my solutions presentation: "We want to find the most comfortable option in the following four areas..."
Ultimately, once you have done some research on what to expect to spend and then testing to prove your levels of comfort, you will find that more expensive does not necessarily mean more comfortable or even better. According to Englander's website (which I do not carry) you should expect to find a GOOD queen set (not specialty) coiled mattress for between $1000 and $1500 dollars (which should include the customer service elements of warranty, delivery, comfort exchange, durability and comfort). Specialty will probably be more, but there are options that can easily put you into that range without having to break the bank. Easy test: Go find 5 pillow top mattresses in your local store (tell the sales agent to leave you alone... seriously) at 5 different price points. You will probably find that the top 2 or 3 can feel really good without having to like the most expensive one... hope this helps!
Sleep Well 'joed"! |
I think both latex mattress and memory form mattress have very distinct, different feel from the traditional inner spring matress. Latex matress has a bouncy feeling, memory form has a sink in feeling, they are all very different from inner spring. I can imagine not everybody like the feelings. As Pure bliss latex mattress(nutrition, 11" of latex) owners of 2 months, my husband and I are very happy with our latex mattress, it's very comfortable to us. I think whether latex/memory form mattress works or not is a very individual thing. |
I don't know about other people. But I got the softest latex mattress and it is killing me. I am returning it. I got taken in by the salesmen pitch. The soft latex is only soft for less then 1 minute and then it starts to pushback. I sink in too much and it is pushing back firmly. I now have shoulder pains with I did not have before I bought this. I sleep on polyurethane sofa which does not pushback.
I have tried tempurpedic beds. I found that basic cloud is too firm for me. The other cloud series - I sink in too much and am touching the base foam. I have tried the contour series. I find them too firm for me. I have tried Rhapsody at a friends house. It strated fine and it fizzled. It softened up where I weighed the heaviest - hips/buttocks. I have tried sleeping on allura. And it is only "seems" good when I sleep on my back. and finally I can't afford a 7000 dollar Grand bed. So if there is any "soft latex bed " in "real life" kindly tell me. Because I have not found it. I don't know why budgy is telling "99%" of the people like latex.To me right now is just uncomfortable piece of rubber which they fancifully call "latex". Beware of the salemen. I might just go back to springs. This message was modified Dec 6, 2011 by Joed
|
My old latex bed felt too hard and too soft at the same time. Pressure points on hips, but made my back hurt. And it didn't make my back hurt because it was too firm - sleeping on an old non-foamcore futon in spare bedroom, VERY firm, always makes my back feel way better overnight. |
Not sure what you are thinking with this. Latex actually has one of the best pressure point relief of any mattress in the industry and will do so equally to any polyurethe foam mattress. Latex recovers much faster than momory foam, but does not push back any harder than memory foam. The push back factor is exactly the same as memory foam and this is based on gravity and weight. If you push down with 100lbs you will sink down until the latex or memory foam resists 100lbs of force. The pressue apllied to you is equal. If it is less resistance then you will continue to sink until equal pressure is met. If it is pushing back with greater resistance then you will continue to raise higher. The comfort level is personal preferance. Just like all other foams Latex comes in extra firm, med, plush to very soft. That is personal preferance. I have had my latex bed for 11yrs now and I wouldnt change it out for anything. I personally found memory foam mattress to be uncomfortable and made my shoulders hurt, but that was a firmer one. Some of the softer ones like the Tempurpedic Cloud I could live with, but none are a comfortable as my latex bed. With that said another friend of mine swears by his Tempurpedic and wouldnt trade it for the world as it is very comfortable to him (Way to hard for me) Talking with others I find many that love both products and I find some that cant sleep on either. To say latex has more push back is completely false. At least until they come out with some new product that defiy's the laws of physics and gravity. |
Not sure why you are saying Mattress Firm doesnt carry latex mattress. They have latex on their website and in the local stores around here. They also talk about the reason some of the Simmons or Sealy mattress's sets are so expensive is because they use latex and latex is one of the highest quality materials you can get in the bedding industry. This is what their sales reps will tell you. Mattress Giant also sells Latex beds, so does sleepy's as will most of your largest mattress compainies. None of those compaines has stopped carrying latex beds so you might want to check your data again. Many funiture stores do not carry latex, but even most of the larger funiture stores and/or high end funitures will carry latex beds. it is naive to beieve all mattress retailers would carry them if it was a great product. Tempurpedic is a great product, but not all retailers carry them. Sealy Makes great mattress sets, but not all retailers carry them. So stating "If a product is so good all retailers would carry them" is flawed. |
|
You still have not answered my question about whether your mattress truly is all latex....did you read the law label yet to see the material contents? |
Your "claim" about latex's pushback is a not true. After my experiences, I have learned not to trust salesmen. This message was modified Dec 7, 2011 by Joed
|
To repeat, It is 6 inch of latex on 8 inches of soy foam. 2 inch of celsion over 1 inch of dunlop over 3 inch of talalay. All over 8 inch of soy foam. This message was modified Dec 7, 2011 by Joed
|
And based on this mattress you say latex is no good for anyone? theres a whole lot of polyfoam in the mattress itself too...I bet if you cut open the top quilting layer it is a thin layer of polyurethane before the latex too. |
|
Latex has been around since the 40's and is still the longest lasting material in the bedding industry. Still need a few more years in to tell if Tempurpedic will hold as long and they are making a good showing. Dont get me worng. I am not saying the High Density Memory foams are a bad product or worse then latex. They are both excellent products with great support and durability. To choose one fromt he other is really a matter of personal preference for comfort. |
Just a suggestion you might try before anyone gives up on their latex- make sure it's not bound too tightly, and that there's as little as possible between your body & the latex itself. Once I ditched the very nice but too thick embroidered mattress cover, and cut off the really tight fabric that the latex block was directly cased within, the feel was 100% different. ONly then could my shoulders & hips sink in enough so that the foam between those points could rise to support the arch of my back. Nothing between myself & the latex except one sheet & a wrap-around cover that's as thin as a sheet, & a set of actual springs under the latex- then all my foam & foundation swapping ended. While the exact opposite was necessary for me to sleep on memory foam- the thicker & tighter the encasement, the less I found the memory foam shied away from the contours' heat it contacted. Ultimately memory foam or latex depends on what your biggest problem is, pressure points or support, but sometimes little details in what's above & below the foam itself can result in huge performance changes for you. It's just tough to draw blanket conclusions of either in a vacuum, especially for how different we all are, and how differently they can all be setup.
|
In my extensive mattress shopping this year, I found it 'insanely difficult' to really know a mattress from trying in the store. Man, what a difference it makes from trying a mattress for 15 minutes at a time to sleeping on it for 8 hours a night. I laid on the iComfort Revolution SO much before buying it, it was ridiculous. I really thought it was going to work. I could detect no problems in the store. It didn't seem like my back or neck would have problems with it. I had no idea it would end up sleeping a little warm. It took a week or two weeks for neck discomfort to emerge. I hear some states don't allow returns on mattresses. That's insane! Mattress shopping for quite a few people is one of the most difficult things to choose among. People in great shape and no joint problems can sleep on most things, stay in various hotels and do fine. Then there's the rest of us who need specialty mattresses. |
A new mattress truly is like a piece of machinery at your local gym. Let's use a treadmill and an elliptical machine. Many people can "run 5 miles" on a treadmill and when they are first introduced to the elliptical, they can barely finish 1-2 miles. Is it fair to say the elliptical machine is a failure or the incorrect machine? Simply put, no. the elliptical machine uses your arms as well as your legs AND it is a very controlled motion for the muscle groups in the lower half of your body. If you keep trying the elliptical for the next couple of weeks, you find that pretty soon you are up to yuor "5 miles" and you have stopped sweating like the entire army in basic training! You may still even feel some soreness for those several weeks as you keep pushing yourself on the elliptical, but ultimately you can feel the benefits and your body continues to adapt. The longer you have slept on a bed in poor condition, or with the wrong support or levels of comfort for you, the longer it may take to find the correct bed for YOUR needs. It seems that throughout these posts you have tried several things to no avail, but I have not seen (and I may have missed it) how long you have actually tried some of these beds (it is a lot to read to get all of the facts) but I submit that any soreness felt during the first 5-8 weeks could literally be the change your spine and back muscles experience as they are experiencing the benefits of the new sleep system... if the problem, though is in the pressure points on your hips or shoulders, that won't change with extended use once the bed has been conditioned (or broken in). As a reminder, I am a sleep consultant and have been doing this for only about 5 years, but I spend countless hours reading, researching and discussing the effects of different support systems and different physical response of individuals so that I stop trying to sell a square and spend more time custom fitting my clients with the proper comfort, support and price. Even with 90-120 days to make an exchange or return, I have less than 4% of my sales ever come back because of the time I spend listening and discussing their responses and less time talking about the things my manufacturer reps tell about why their bed is better than everyone else's... millions of backs and almost as many sleep systems, just gotta find the right one for you!
Sleep well, Joed! |
I've chronicled my recent mattress shopping adventures/nightmare in agonizing detail all over this site. But I am back to comment on this Latex thread. First, hardly anyone seems to mention that the Latex seems to sleep HOT. I know, I know, it's not supposed to...only Memory Foam is hot. But I am absolutely convinced that our new S&F Latex bed is much warmer than previous, old mattress. True, it has a pillowtop -- and I suspect that is part of the problem. But I also think the Latex itself is an issue -- it doesn't breathe. What do the experts/salespeople have to say about this? Better yet, what do actual buyers have to say? Because I don't trust anyone in the industry. I also think the Latex gives that "pushback" sensation that has been mentioned here several times. In that regard, it is not comfortable. I am on the verge of exchanging our current bed for the non-pillowtop version OR returning it and buying a non-latex model of some sort. But this is a real dilemma -- finding a bed (that doesn't cost a fortune) that is COOL and doesn't PUSH BACK! |
Isn't latex about the most expensive bed material ? So if you feel it "pushes back" for you, it seems like not going latex helps you with the "costs a fortune" thing. I decided I really didn't like the 6" latex core from an old mattress I disassembled, instead opting to go with a much cheaper core of p/u (LUX and HD36) from FBM. I feel your pain, as far as finding something you like - I am trying to converge on something I like by experimenting with layers. The fact my girlfriend wants to set up a guest bed, and isn't real particular about it, gives me more options. |
If you are in the pillow-top, another disadvantage will be that the farther you sink into the bed, the hotter you will sleep as you are reducing the amount of airflow coming in contact with your skin. Latex, like other foams and even coils, come in various firmnesses (foam uses ILD to measure and coils are typically depicted in gauge). I do not remember if I posted on one of your other threads or in response to this earlier, but here you go: Whatever the combination of foams (any type) and coils (any type), there are a couple of things to consider:
My parents sleep on a Stearns and Foster pillow top with latex and memory foam and have not had some of the same issues you describe, but they are different people, so let me encourage you to go try the bed(s) you think you may want to exchange for and tell the salesperson (after you ask any pertinent questions) to leave you alone and spend 15-20 minutes (per bed) to see if you begin to feel any heat build-up, pressure points, push-back, etc. If you are, keep looking. The muscles in the human back are involuntary and will only relax (release) once they recognize enough support to hold the spine in position without their assistance... it takes on average 12-15 minutes to recognize this support. It isn't a night of sleeping, but it will help eliminate some beds. Once you find "the one" and you decide to get it... please spend at least 4-5 weeks sleeping on it to allow the bed to be broken in and your back to both experience proper support and allow the change in your body temperature to adjust. Yes, you may sleep warmer, especially during the first few weeks, especially if your last bed created multiple pressure points. Those pressure points reduce blood flow creating a cooler sensation/experience in the attached limbs. Once regular blood flow is re-introduced to those limbs during sleep, you will feel warmer, but the body is an amazing thing and it will adjust in just a few weeks. Not to mention, the increased blood flow does in actuality help your body heal itself quicker (more work is being done in your body while you sleep... but you feel more rested when you wake!) Hope this answers some questions "boopboopadoop"... sleep well! |
|
Hey Joed -- I hope you get this message, several years since the last post. I'm curious if you ever found a good solution. Your experience on latex sounds exactly like mine. Pretty frustrating after spending over $4000 for two twin XL latex beds, followed by a couple of expensive latex toppers hoping to fix the problem. |