Need help... change mattress or add Topper?
Jun 21, 2010 12:20 AM
Joined: Jun 21, 2010
Points: 15
Hi everyone,

 

 

GREAT FORUM... this is m first post...

 

I am in a HUGE dillemma right now with my current mattress purchase. I had a saggy Serta mattress that they didn't warranty as it wasn't saggins 1.5" without any weight on it (a lot more if you slept on it). So, I decided to go out and get myself a new set. From past experiences with Serta and Sealy, I decided to go Simmons and pocket Coil.

 

I purchased a FIRM Simmons, World Class (980 springs), Medium Pillowtop (not as big of Eurotop, 1.5-2" top of memroy/latex mix). I took it home and slept on it... it feels OK if I sleep on my back, but I start on my side, and end up on my back... so now it's starting to hurt my shoulders as I get pressure points on it. My girlfried also doesn't like it as it's too hard for her.

 

So, then I started searching online and learned a lot, and also went back and tried literally EVERY bed in the store, I got 30-days for exhange! I AM NOW MORE CONFUSED THAN EVER! :(

My options are:

1. Get the same Simmons mattress with bigger pillowtop (Eurotop) to help with shoulder

2. Get a Stearns and Fosters Eurotop (kind of in between Simmong Eurotop, and my current Simmons)

3. Get a Stearns and Fosters Tighttop (no pillow top), and add a Natural Latext 2" Mattress Topper

 

I got the following questions:

- Is Simon/Fosters mid-range mattresses any better than Simmons World Class?

- Would Eurotop of 3-4" have any issues with long-term wear?

- If I want to get a Latex Topper, what's the best brand, best kind (weight), and where to get it from?

 

I am leaning towards #3, but I kind of DO NOT like a FLAT mattress topper underneath my sheets... just looks and feels cheap! Will also take away from the natural fibers of mattress as well as the convoluted shape. Is there a Latex topper that is covered like a mattress I can just add?

 

Thanks for any help and I appreciate quick responses as I have only 3 more days to exhange the mattress. I can't really return it (20% restocking fee).

 

Thanks in advance!

This message was modified Jun 21, 2010 by alexb
Re: Need help... change mattress or add Topper?
Reply #14 Jul 4, 2010 10:41 AM
Joined: Apr 21, 2010
Points: 58
you should be aware that all simmons mattresses made now, as opposed to a decade ago, are soft. even those rated by them as firm. they use a thin coil gauge in the coils and a ton of soft padding. if you don't need much back support go for it. I weigh under90 pounds and sank into a "firm" simmons. totally collapsed when I sat on the edge 
Re: Need help... change mattress or add Topper?
Reply #15 Jul 5, 2010 6:02 PM
Location: L.A. area
Joined: Jan 18, 2008
Points: 1161
I would never buy a Simmons anything. Had one that wore out in less than a year.
Re: Need help... change mattress or add Topper?
Reply #16 Jul 12, 2010 11:10 PM
Joined: Jun 21, 2010
Points: 15
Any other comments? I got till 15th to swap mattress.
Re: Need help... change mattress or add Topper?
Reply #17 Jul 13, 2010 2:14 PM
Location: Yosemite area
Joined: Sep 10, 2008
Points: 249
I don't know about the springs or the foam that is in your mattress, sounds okay to me.  I think you might just need a topper to make a total of about 4" of cushion above the springs.  If you bed has 2" you need about 2" more.  You could try a polyfill topper...they feel great.

I would NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVERNEVER again buy a Stearns and Foster bed.  They are owned by Sealy, and use cheap foam, breaks down quickly(try 3 months) and don't honor warranties. It was so bad, first I slept on my side of the bed until the hips cratered, then I slept in the center until that failed, then I slept on the very edge of the bed until I couldn't stand it anymore.  I ONLY WEIGHED 115#!   I had to give my new bed to a friend who liked it for about five minutes and has hated it ever since.  It is probably three years old now and is a piece of garbage.  Don't fall for the name.  That's why they bought the name...so they could charge more for crud.

Kait

Re: Need help... change mattress or add Topper?
Reply #18 Jul 14, 2010 3:58 AM
Joined: Jun 21, 2010
Points: 15
Thanks Kait. I was told S&F has changed their Springs and foams complete for this year, but I've seen those bad reviews of sagging bed. I just checked the S&F today again, and they have a good sale, so option is either to keep Simmons I got and add a topper, or to get the S&F that's got more foam on top (says it's a combo of Latex and Memory Foam).

 

Kait wrote:

I don't know about the springs or the foam that is in your mattress, sounds okay to me.  I think you might just need a topper to make a total of about 4" of cushion above the springs.  If you bed has 2" you need about 2" more.  You could try a polyfill topper...they feel great.

 

I would NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVER NEVERNEVER again buy a Stearns and Foster bed.  They are owned by Sealy, and use cheap foam, breaks down quickly(try 3 months) and don't honor warranties. It was so bad, first I slept on my side of the bed until the hips cratered, then I slept in the center until that failed, then I slept on the very edge of the bed until I couldn't stand it anymore.  I ONLY WEIGHED 115#!   I had to give my new bed to a friend who liked it for about five minutes and has hated it ever since.  It is probably three years old now and is a piece of garbage.  Don't fall for the name.  That's why they bought the name...so they could charge more for crud.

Kait



Recent Posts