Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Apr 1, 2010 12:43 PM
Joined: Apr 1, 2010
Points: 13
I have no problems with the way a new innerspring mattress sleeps.. I am just irritated that they turn into a pile of garbage in a couple years. Do I have any options other than purchasing a junker from a "warehouse" store?
Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #1 Apr 1, 2010 1:15 PM
Joined: Dec 17, 2009
Points: 850
There are good coil mattresses, although they will be much more costly than a normal coil mattress, brands that build them well:

Hastens, Vi-Spring, Hypnos, Green Sleep, Carpe Diem, Royal Pedic, Mc Roskey, Shifman, and I know there are others just not coming to my mind at the moment. 

Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #2 Apr 1, 2010 1:37 PM
Joined: Apr 1, 2010
Points: 13
ok.. thanks for the help! so is there something in between a total junker and a pricey, hand-made piece of heaven?
Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #3 Apr 1, 2010 3:16 PM
Location: L.A. area
Joined: Jan 18, 2008
Points: 1161
I've heard good things about "A Better Bed" in Fresno, but I can't vouch for them personally.

There are probably other small manufacturers like this, in out of the way places but I'm not aware of them.

While the beds Budgy mentioned meet his criteria for being well made that does not necessarily mean they will be worth the money to you, and I don't believe they always offer a good sleep trial. I know for sure I've read some reviews of customers who were not satisfied with some of those mattresses he lists. My point is not to knock them, only to say that if you are going to pay a LOT of money for a mattress, and especially if you have sleep or mattress "issues", you may only want to buy from someone who gives a good sleep trial guarantee.

Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #4 Apr 1, 2010 3:39 PM
Joined: May 3, 2008
Points: 827
Gardner's Mattresses makes spring mattresses and puts latex layers on the top.  Not sure what else they make.  But visit their website.  There is someone here who bought one and liked it.  But it was too firm and they added 3" of soft latex over that.

If I lived near Boston (I think) I would visit that store.

Does Natura make innerspring?

Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #5 Apr 1, 2010 3:54 PM
Joined: Nov 4, 2008
Points: 223
Check out Omaha Bedding company, too. They make quality stuff by hand, and the prices aren't awful ($1200 or so for a king-size mattress). I slept on it in a hotel in San Francisco, and it was wonderful.
Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #6 Apr 1, 2010 3:56 PM
Joined: Dec 17, 2009
Points: 850
jimsocal wrote:

I've heard good things about "A Better Bed" in Fresno, but I can't vouch for them personally.

There are probably other small manufacturers like this, in out of the way places but I'm not aware of them.

While the beds Budgy mentioned meet his criteria for being well made that does not necessarily mean they will be worth the money to you, and I don't believe they always offer a good sleep trial. I know for sure I've read some reviews of customers who were not satisfied with some of those mattresses he lists. My point is not to knock them, only to say that if you are going to pay a LOT of money for a mattress, and especially if you have sleep or mattress "issues", you may only want to buy from someone who gives a good sleep trial guarantee.


Truth be spoken. 

I have to agree...I guess I wasn't really trying to blindly recommend them....in reality the very best inbetween option (and for some the very best regardless of price) is a 100% latex mattress. 

Leo: yes actually.  Natura just started making coil mattresses.  They are for the price I think better value than most brands because they use some latex and they are quilted with legitimate amounts of wool and cotton on top.  To be fair as much as I am a huge fan of Natura as a company these beds are not really made to outlast standard coil mattresses...maybe a little better, but they are really just meant to be a healthier nights sleep.  They still use a couple inches of soy based pu foam,  but the whole point is the first couple layers you are actually sleeping on are wool and cotton instead of polyester and polyurethane. 

Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #7 Apr 1, 2010 4:16 PM
Joined: May 3, 2008
Points: 827
What kind of fire retardants are you looking to avoid or get?  That is another issue you need to ask yourself.  That is why I would look at Gardner (not sure about theirs) and Natura.  Look for organic or make sure they say what it is.  I read on my tag (wool pad) of Natura that they use Boric Acid on the mattresses that aren't labeled organic.  At least they tell you!  But I  wouldn't buy it, I don't care what "they" say; if it kills bugs (and it does) what does it do to you?
Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #8 Apr 1, 2010 4:23 PM
Joined: Dec 17, 2009
Points: 850
Truth, they use the boric acid in the cotton batting underneath the wool layer.  Better than formaldehyde, and these don't have that offensive new mattress smell to them.  But yeah, buying (CERTIFIED) organic is the best way to avoid chemicals altogether. 
Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #9 Apr 1, 2010 4:36 PM
Joined: May 3, 2008
Points: 827
I found a Natura for $5,000 or more (queen size) from Sears.  Wonder if I can get that 50% off on their sales?

I am impressed with some of their products.  They do tell you what is in them, which I find refreshing!

Gardner mattresses click here look so fascinating.  They have pocket coils, and some with latex on top.  Some that have cotton batting only.  Just make sure you don't get one with the "foam" in it.  They will ship all over US, but what a fee that would be for me.

Re: Is there such thing as a well-made innerspring mattress any more?
Reply #10 Apr 1, 2010 4:37 PM
Joined: May 3, 2008
Points: 827
budgy wrote:

Truth, they use the boric acid in the cotton batting underneath the wool layer.  Better than formaldehyde, and these don't have that offensive new mattress smell to them.  But yeah, buying (CERTIFIED) organic is the best way to avoid chemicals altogether. 

Which Natura mattresses do you like Budgy?  They do sell on with slats, I just wish I could find one too look at.

Recent Posts