|
I'm trying to get on board the latex bandwaggon, though i keep ending back at square one- defaulting back to another sealy posturepedic firm that will surely crater again within a few years- if i can't arrive at a more confident decision about which latex mattress to buy. that they are sight unseen, off the internet, isn't helping. The conventional mattress I like, sealy's signature firm (or a s&f ultra firm), the springs are topped with more "marvelux" layers than anything else, but I hesitate to order raw conventional "lux" foam (assuming it's similar) to use as a base as you guys do for your d.i.y. projects, because I fear the stench. since latex ild's aren't very consistent when compared across vulcanization techniques, or even with the same process across different companies, I can't really depend on that as an objective measure. apparently no more reliable than terms like "natural" vs. "organic" vs. "botanical" in this industry. So I am looking for what anyone with experience would recommend in latex to someone who likes the very firmest conventional mattresses (they rarely even have them in the showroom, just up to cushion firm). You might wonder why I would consider latex at all in that case, but obviously the durability/longevity of latex would appeal to anyone, & I really did like the FEEL of the only latex models i tried (ashley house brand), only imagining if that same feel could be firmed up alot (assuming those are not opposing concepts). I like that springy feeling and consistent support, which makes me want to try a much firmer version of it. Of course ashley's pamphlet didn't list their ILD's, so I don't even know what my starting point is. b.t.w. ashley's is only a few inches of latex topper over conventional foam, so I might be liking all the conventional foam underneath more than anything, i just don't know. i have no experience with raw blocks of any type of foam. Supposedly the conventional spring mattresses I prefer are almost like sleeping on a carpeted floor ("comfort rating" of 2.5 on 1-10 scale), and maybe it is that way to someone alot lighter. But even the firmest ones give plenty under me. I just don't like to sink in THROUGH top layers, like with memory foam (eliminated), or any kind of pillowtops (obviously eliminated). My criteria: 1. FIrmest latex, as close to the level of the ultra firm conventional mattresses as possible. this has me looking to the brands that advertise 44 ild, but I don't know that the likes of foamorder's or sleep/bears' 44 ild's will necessarily be firmer than other brands with lower ratings. 1a. No smell/stench. apparently that will be as natural as possible, best washed, with the least chemicals- why the habitat botanical speel kind of sucked me in, but I've read too many reviews from big guys who bottom out on their 6" version, and that's their firmest. ild in mid 20's. 3. Price. i'm looking at the lower end brands here (even the conventional sealy signature firm set will be pushing my budget right now), but i am willing to splurge maybe a little more on what is becoming a medical necessity. I'm currently sleeping on the very edges of my sealy firm (still under "warranty"!) to keep my back supported well enough. but imagining what the markup is on these blocks of raw foam, maybe it is just a coincidence that the range of popular latex match the price structure of conventional mattresses. though i realize manufacturers' costs are irrelevant vs. what people are willing to pay for something. and either way, if it lasts longer than my innerspring mattresses, & if i sleep well on it, i'll try not to care what the markup is/ 4. quality outside of durability, firmness, & being odor free, I don't care about finish, imperfections in the foam (eg with dunlop vs. talalay) that i won't FEEL, what the foam looks like, beveling/faux fluting etc. carved into the edges, embroidery on the cover (though a heavy duty zipper & a cover that FITS would be nice). 5. simplicity. i'd rather not have to put together alot of loose components, especially not from different sellers or too much d.i.y. i'd rather not get the one whose layers you have to shuffle, rotate, flip every four months, & finding a cover that will fit a frankenbed without being too loose etc. but if i have to sacrifice any of these requirements, simplicity is my lowest priority. i have not ruled out getting as firm a 6" +core as i can find, then experimenting with toppers. if i KNEW the smell would go away, and that i could stomach it in the meantime, i'd just go for a block of that 55 ild hiqh quality conventional lux foam, and nice firm latex topper. finding a cover, even if I have to buy, try, & return a couple, wont' be as expensive or difficult as shipping a hundred pounds of FOAM (not even going to do that, which is another reason why i don't want to spend thousands on foam- what i buy, i'm keeping). Any suggestions or recommendations appreciated. |
|
i read eagle's update, which just added to my confusion. he can't help the data, only records it. i appreciate his honesty anyway. so in the meantime i've been reading alot of JimS.C.'s posts, and am now considering something more radical. sending priority #5 now compeltely out the window obviously. i already know i get quality sleep on a firm spring mattresses0 in the short term,a nd the main reason i want to go latex is i hope it lasts longer than just a couple of years (& do actually like the feel of latex ive tried too). so working under the assumption that what gives out FIRST on spring mattresses are the comfort layers on top getting compressed, & that the springs will still be good for much longer, i'm thinking of either: 1. getting the cheapest spring bed i can find that has the heaviest guage hardest tempered steel springs possible, then immediately removing the cheap foam on top and replacing it w/lthe firmest latex layers available when it's still new like jim did (Basically still using springs as my core instead of a core of latx, & using latex on top). or 2. just buying yet another sealy/s&f ultra firm, that i already know works for me. which would be too expensive for me to immediately buy enough latex to "refill" it via surgery, so i would still have that as an option down the line when their marvelux layers get compressed. of course that's assuming the springs are not the weakest link (i;m not so sure, but will find out with my current p.p. before dumping it). mabye ill find something so obvious for the project- something with really heavy duty springs, that's cheap only because it has garbage for comfort layers, i'l go that route. so i'm looking to jim for advice on option #1. if i go with another quality spring mattress, i might try just having ONE modestly priced latex topper- which might prolong the life of the layers inside the mattress anyway, hopefully the springs too. so it will still be useable when i do surgery d.t.l. |
|
I might've missed something here, but if you already own a mattress you liked before the foam gave out, the springs should still be good....why not just take that one apart and figure out what foam you like? Seems cheaper and you'll certainly learn a lot. I have found that I like offset coil springs the best of anything for the foundation of my mattress. I don't like all-foam mattresses, be it memory foam or latex or even PU foam. There is a special feel from the springs that just feels great to sleep on(for me). If you know what is broke, maybe just fix that part and call it good. Kait |
|
Kait wrote: I might've missed something here, but if you already own a mattress you liked before the foam gave out, the springs should still be good....why not just take that one apart and figure out what foam you like? Seems cheaper and you'll certainly learn a lot. I have found that I like offset coil springs the best of anything for the foundation of my mattress. I don't like all-foam mattresses, be it memory foam or latex or even PU foam. There is a special feel from the springs that just feels great to sleep on(for me). If you know what is broke, maybe just fix that part and call it good. Kait because you're really paying attention (thanks). yeah i might open this one up for the learning experience, but will not invest in any replacement foam for it. because whatever i do i'm really wanting to upgrade from a full to at least a full-xl or queen if i can swing it. i've even had TWIN-xl i prefer over full. anyway, now i have coil type research ahead of me. i think i have interlocked springs right now, but will look into offset. i'm just glad i quit ignoring this "hybrid" option in time before going all foam latex, abandoning what's familiar completley. but this will be a PROJECT, & trying that costco 10 inch on sale is so simple & tempting. i'm certain it won't be firm enough, it's just so hard to deny because it's the lowest risk/hassle purchase, with absolutely 0 loss return among all foam options (for me). |
|
Considering what you've said so far about the desired firmness of your mattress, the Costco bed will almost certainly be way too soft for you. Except for 3-4", there are some pretty soft layers in there - even for Dunop. Here is a quote from the product description: "Sleep Science Softness Scale – Soft/Medium on one side and Medium on the other" This message was modified Dec 2, 2009 by KimberlyH
|
|
Hey, I was paying attention, how about that?! Anyway, the Signature line as I recall from all of my investigations, has the offset coils like mine does! As a matter of fact, the Signature line was the closest to the hotel bed I slept on that I loved. I think you are in the misery boat that only mattress surgery will solve. First, if you have a King, you don't have to do both sides at first(unless your partner is unhappy too...). I'd still open up the mattress(I used an Exacto knife)on three sides, leaving the head side intact. I cut right below the piping. A king is the size of two twins, so when I chose to experiment I got twin sized pieces(just wrestling with ONE king sized piece of 2" latex to try to return it was enough to convince me of that). I'm going to hazzard a guess that your foam is cheap P/U foam and it stopped performing where you sleep, hence the flat spot. Here's what I learned about foam from my foam guy: Foam is a medium that holds little air bubbles inside it, as the foam is used, the air bubbles are compressed, and they end up popping into adjoining bubbles, eventually becoming larger. The buoyancy of foam depends on these bubbles remaining intact...when the bubbles are burst the foam softens. THAT IS WHY YOU CAN HAVE FOAM THAT LOOK S AND FEELS JUST FINE TO YOUR HAND, BUT IT IS NOT SUPPORTIVE ANYMORE! I found that very important in my saddle equipment...poor horses are being ridden with foam as a pad, the rider thinks things are just fine, but the horse suffers needless pain. Anyway, the cheaper the foam, the quicker it can break down, so when it does your back knows it. The better foams take longer to die, maybe because the medium is more resistant to popping. I think that is why Latex lasts so long, it is a rubber medium, very stretchy. So, if you have good springs and I bet you do, you just have to remove the stuff that is in there and replace it with what you want to sleep on. If the mattress was okay for awhile, but then caved where you slept, the middle should still be okay, possibly cut that out and move it to one side? Or take some and go to a foam store or an upholstry shop, or somesuch and find what you need to replace it. Less is typically more. Where these bedmakers do us a disservice is by putting in too many inches of padding(foam) that breaks down and makes the bed unusable(aha! That's why bed surgery!). I don't think it is the springs that are bad, just the stupid foam. Don't be afraid of the bed. It cannot make it worse, it can only make it better. Forgot to mention, best tool for cutting the foam in/around the bed without hurting the other stuff: electric carving knife. Great tool. Use it all the time on foam. The foam in your mattress will be glued together, I used a butter knife to slice between it. Kait This message was modified Dec 2, 2009 by Kait
|
|
thanks. all i've read on signature's "posturetech coils with posture channels"(beyond marketing jargon) is that they're14gauge 5 1/2" tall hourglass coils with a sensory arm. i understand offset is the more expensive/preferred type of hourglass coil, so they may very well be that. Apparently sealy also has one called "triple offset coils" whose construction they break down in greater detail, but haven't found any models outside the uk with them (& i see they are in your sealy hotel bed!). Either way, i trust you when you say my springs are still good long after the foam's tiny bubbles have ruptured- but i'm still not fixing this one. (here we go): i sleep diagonally, which is fine until the sink in the middle gets too bad. at that point i'm sleeping (vertically) on the very edges of my bed where it's still actually firm, but have to put a chest at the end of it with blanket & pillow on top as a sort of bed extender (ridiculous!) for my feet. if i wake up on my stomach with my feet hanging off the end of the bed & my legs locked out straight, my knees are killing me (this isn't an issue until after a few years in, because i'm still diagonal- nor on a full xl or even twin xl since they are a few inches longer than a full- i can sleep on those in any position). anyway i'm thinking that's why they wear out so fast. sleeping diagonally puts my hips in the same exact spot every day, no matter which diagonal i choose to orient myself... my heaviest parts are always smashing the center of the X. difficult to explain... well i tried to save you from t.mi but you really wanted me to keep that full. now with a queen or full XL, rotating will actually make a difference. more even distribution of the the wear/tear (along with losing weight) will delay foam compression at any one spot. but even when that happens again, since i know the springs will still be solid at that point, i can operate on it whenever. queen or full xl. king is out even if i could afford it (tight on space). Posturetech:
Considering what you've said so far about the desired firmness of your mattress, the Costco bed will almost certainly be way too soft for you. Except for 3-4", there are some pretty soft layers in there - even for Dunop. Here is a quote from the product description: "Sleep Science Softness Scale – Soft/Medium on one side and Medium on the other" Thanks for the reality check. regardless of how low risk/hassle/cost, none of that will matter once i'm sleeping on it. I have to avoid the mental gynmastics & just accept the fact that there are no shortcuts here. i'll either be buying a higher end signature & operate when necessary, or find the lowest end model that still has the high quality coils- then use the savings under my budget to buy latex at the same time & operate immediately. |
|
Here's something to remember: The higher end you go in a particular line, the MORE foam you get. Really. I asked. I think the lowest bed had like 7" and it went up from there. The reason I mentioned cutting open your Signature is because regardless of how you sleep, it probably is the foam that died and not the springs, unless your bed is many years old. I have the same issue of all my weight being in the same spot....exactly halfway down the mattress is the spot. Plus I sleep on my back or sides, so there is always a concentration there. We have a Ca King so no revolving it. I have in the past(S & F mattress) slept all over the mattress after the butt-dent began...in the middle of the bed, along all the perimeters, everyplace. Yep, you start to get really upset when you are clinging to the edge of the mattress and still cannot find comfort. All I'm saying is that if you slice the thing open and just make your own comfort layers you should find out really fast if it is just the padding or not. Kait |