Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Aug 12, 2011 1:57 AM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 20
First I have to say "thank you" for this forum.  I have learned a lot.   :-)

I'm pretty sold on the idea of getting a latex mattress.  I like the naturalness, and  I like the ideas of swapping out pieces.   My husband and I did stop at Savvyrest, during a trip down south in June, and I liked their product, but not the fact that we cannot get a refund, plus their prices are higher than some.

I think that I need a pretty firm mattress, while my husband did seem to like the softer ones when we stopped at Savvy Rest.   

Basically, we seem to be gravitating towards the suggestions on this forum like sleepez and mattress.net, though I do like the flexibility of sleepez vs mattress.net.

I did want to ask about this clip I just saw regarding talalay vs. dunlop.    The original poster (sorry, I cannot remember which post)  said that it convinced them of talalay vs. dunlop.

I also was pretty sold on getting dunlop, except for possibly a talalay topper, until I saw the clip:  

http://www.flobeds.com/AboutLatexLinks.htm#TalalayVsDunlop

I also wish there was some sort of tally to show what people ultimately buy...the ratings here are challenging to follow.

I'd appreciate any thoughts about this.   My old mattress is probably causing me much unneeded pain in the meantime!

TIA!

Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop??
Reply #12 Aug 22, 2011 2:02 PM
Joined: Aug 1, 2009
Points: 175
I'm no expert (and I haven't been here on the forum for a couple years), but I just added another Talalay topper (2" 32 ILD from SleepLikeABear) under my 1" Talalay topper (1" 24 ILD), because the 2" Dunlop topper that I'd had there, and have now removed, had cratered. It was wonderful for several months, but it gradually lost springiness where I sink in the most (hip area). And I'm a lightweight (5'6", 120 lb or so), so I was kinda surprised about that. 

I don't know what the ILD of the Dunlop piece was -- I got it from Overstock.com, knowing it'd be a crapshoot, but it had good reviews and the price was right, so I tried it. And it was really great for a while... and then it wasn't.

I've had the 32 ILD topper for just a few nights, so I'm not sure if I like it yet. (I'm using these on top of a minimalist, firm, flippable innerspring mattress, bought a few years ago from a local company.) I also had a polyfill fiberbed, about an inch thick, on top of the latex toppers. I just took that off today, because it has also flattened in the hip area over time, and I'm waking up with some lower back pain. (It was a great buy at Kohl's, I think, and it lasted several years, maybe 5 or 6. Everywhere other than the hip area is still nice & cushy.)

Long way of saying: My guess is that Dunlop is fine for a core, but Talalay might be better for a topper. One more data point for you, anyway.

-Catherine

-------

Edited to add:

Never mind. I have no idea what that Overstock.com latex piece actually was -- could have been some cheap synthetic blend (or all synthetic), rather than natural Dunlop-processed latex. It had no labels of any kind. Natural Dunlop latex probably would not have cratered after a few months.

This message was modified Dec 9, 2011 by Catherine
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #13 Aug 22, 2011 4:09 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 20
slpngoc wrote:

Thanks for the reply.  What configuration of firmness did you get??     I also wonder if I go with Sleepez, if I could fit an additional 1" topper in the mattress - I'll have to ask.

 

I won't sit here and plug for SleepEZ all day, but I'll tell you, they are awfully nice to talk to.  I've talked to Shawn 'bout 3 times and his sister Christina once, and they are very nice.  Also, they did the order right and it came to my doorstep less than 3 days.  'Course that's AZ to CA.

 --------------------------------