Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Aug 12, 2011 1:57 AM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 20
First I have to say "thank you" for this forum.  I have learned a lot.   :-)

I'm pretty sold on the idea of getting a latex mattress.  I like the naturalness, and  I like the ideas of swapping out pieces.   My husband and I did stop at Savvyrest, during a trip down south in June, and I liked their product, but not the fact that we cannot get a refund, plus their prices are higher than some.

I think that I need a pretty firm mattress, while my husband did seem to like the softer ones when we stopped at Savvy Rest.   

Basically, we seem to be gravitating towards the suggestions on this forum like sleepez and mattress.net, though I do like the flexibility of sleepez vs mattress.net.

I did want to ask about this clip I just saw regarding talalay vs. dunlop.    The original poster (sorry, I cannot remember which post)  said that it convinced them of talalay vs. dunlop.

I also was pretty sold on getting dunlop, except for possibly a talalay topper, until I saw the clip:  

http://www.flobeds.com/AboutLatexLinks.htm#TalalayVsDunlop

I also wish there was some sort of tally to show what people ultimately buy...the ratings here are challenging to follow.

I'd appreciate any thoughts about this.   My old mattress is probably causing me much unneeded pain in the meantime!

TIA!

Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #2 Aug 12, 2011 12:02 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 481
That's an interesting video -  So the LI blended talalay slab springs out nicely, looks great after 4 years compressed ...

and the Latex Green (Sri Lanka) all natural Dunlop looks shriveled after 5 years compressed ... hmmmm

I just received a SleepEZ 10000 with 3 talalay layers in firm/med/soft.  I asked Shawn couple days ago what the default configuration is and he said they only send out a Dunlop layer if it is requested.

I can tell you for sure, I am not sinking down a bunch on 3 layers of talalay.  I feel pretty good this morning, but it has only been one night.

I forgot why talalay is their default setup so you'll have to ask him.   As for the blended talalay, it's not like it's all stinky or anything.  I can't see trippin' on blended since apparently 97% of Latex International's talalay is mfrd. in blended....

Last week, an LI rep on phone told me .. btw, the blended talalay does last longer than 100% natural talalay.  FWIW.

This message was modified Aug 12, 2011 by slpngoc
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #3 Aug 12, 2011 12:17 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 481
With all respect to Budgy, I don't know if he works hands on with latex., but to the OP, I would think also talking to several mfrs. (SleepEZ, Flobeds, etc...) that have worked hands on with the different latexes over the years would be good.

Here in SF Bay Area, Natural Mattress Stores has 3 stores with organic / latex beds.  Told me they use Dunlop cores / talalay tops in their 'Awareness' line.

that video is interesting.

I would think it is most important to get good quality latex from the best suppliers which apparently are LI, Latexco, Latex Green, etc...

This message was modified Aug 12, 2011 by slpngoc
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #4 Aug 12, 2011 12:50 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 20
budgy wrote:

If they are both 100% natural they are going to be good quality.  Talalay process is useful for those that want a mattress softer than what is possible using dunlop process, although there are some pretty soft all dunlop mattresses available.  If you ask me dunlop latex has a better durability track record...flobeds doesn't sell dunlop latex so I don't know where that 'sample' came from.  But natural dunlop mattresses are notorious for lasting 20~30 years and in some cases longer...I doubt that talalay would be signicantly more durable since it hasn't been sold in large quantities for as long.  The properties of the polymers used are the most important thing when comparing one latex mattress to another, in theory talalay process latex can never be quite as pure (or as dense) as what is possible with dunlop, all the more leading me to believe dunlop is more durable.  ultimately you should really try to find a store that carries both to see which is most comfortable for you.


That's what I was thinking, that dunlop would last longer.  How long have people been making talalay?   Apparently flobeds used to sell dunlop:

"Originally we could not get our natural latex in Talalay, so we imported natural latex made in the Dunlop process by the container from Sri Lanka. We couldn't help but notice that our Latex International Talalay Latex (blended) kept its shape and resiliency much better than the Dunlop.  As our natural latex mattress sales grew, we kept asking Latex International to consider making a 100% Natural Talalay. Finally in 2005 they did, and FloBeds was first in line. We have never looked back.  In July of 2009, while cleaning out the upper shelves at our Latex Shop, we found some latex cores that had been stored compressed for years. We wondered how dramatic the difference in resiliency would be and wanted to share the study with our customers...even we were surprised at the results."

I'm assuming it ls less expensive to manufacturer talalay, since it uses less latex because of the vacuum process.   I also found out from LI that:

 Most of the latex in the marketplace is a blend. The synthetic or "man-made" rubber is made from SBR or Styrene Butadiene Rubber.  We do produce a natural latex formula although not nearly in the same volumes as our blend.  However, it is generally regarded that the Talalay process creates a more durable latex in terms of resistance to body impressions as well as firmness retention. 

I do wonder if they let that dunlop in the recording sit longer if it would've expanded more.

Lots to consider, plus the fear factor of buying over the internet.   I was reading something by Phoenix last night, and I guess it is time for me to get on the phone and speak to some of these folks.  :-)

 

 

 
 
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #5 Aug 12, 2011 1:01 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 20
slpngoc wrote:

With all respect to Budgy, I don't know if he works hands on with latex., but to the OP, I would think also talking to several mfrs. (SleepEZ, Flobeds, etc...) that have worked hands on with the different latexes over the years would be good.

 

Here in SF Bay Area, Natural Mattress Stores has 3 stores with organic / latex beds.  Told me they use Dunlop cores / talalay tops in their 'Awareness' line.

that video is interesting.

I would think it is most important to get good quality latex from the best suppliers which apparently are LI, Latexco, Latex Green, etc...


What are the main co's that use the good quality latex?     I originally thinking that total dunlop was the way to go, but now I'm wondering about that dunlop core and talalay top.   Sigh.  I know that with some of these products I can return pieces, but I'd really like to get it right the first time if possible.   Plus with mattress.net, it's a one time deal.....but I am wondering if the zipperless mattresses would wear better, or if the convenience of the zipper to exchange pieces would be more practical.   

Mike from LI said that Organic Mattress out of CA or Arizona Premium use their natural talalay.  

Did I mention I'm in Southern NJ?

Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #6 Aug 12, 2011 1:29 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 481
Iris,

I just went for the easier price, and more liberal layer swaps and return policy, although I don't want to do any swaps or returns. 

This is my first foray into all latex, stack layers into zippered cover bed.  I will be reporting, but it'll take some time.

This message was modified Aug 12, 2011 by slpngoc
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #7 Aug 12, 2011 1:37 PM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 481
Iris,

 

I won't sit here and plug for SleepEZ all day, but I'll tell you, they are awfully nice to talk to.  I've talked to Shawn 'bout 3 times and his sister Christina once, and they are very nice.  Also, they did the order right and it came to my doorstep less than 3 days.  'Course that's AZ to CA.

 --------------------------------

Do you have another local mattress stores that have any amount of latex in them?  I tried out Serta Vera Wangs latex line for starters, but don't like the prices.  We're lucky to have Natural Mattress Store with 'organic' latex beds.  I've tried some Englander latex beds a bit, but ewww, they don't have that all latex feel. 

Get out there and look and call.  It's all a risk.  Too early for me to call latex beds great.  I like what I felt at Nat. Mat. Store.

:)

 

Iris wrote:

 


What are the main co's that use the good quality latex?     I originally thinking that total dunlop was the way to go, but now I'm wondering about that dunlop core and talalay top.   Sigh.  I know that with some of these products I can return pieces, but I'd really like to get it right the first time if possible.   Plus with mattress.net, it's a one time deal.....but I am wondering if the zipperless mattresses would wear better, or if the convenience of the zipper to exchange pieces would be more practical.   

Mike from LI said that Organic Mattress out of CA or Arizona Premium use their natural talalay.  

Did I mention I'm in Southern NJ?



This message was modified Aug 12, 2011 by slpngoc
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #8 Aug 12, 2011 2:43 PM
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Joined: May 13, 2011
Points: 170
Hi Iris,

Welcome!.  I think that it may take more time and more reading for you to feel comfortable with your mattress decision.  I did purchase an all Dumlop 10" Savvy Rest because I don't have sleep issues and felt that exchanging layers would be sufficient and I got a discount.  Otherwise I probably would have purchased a SleepEZ as I wanted organic mattress.  This forum seems to have two types of people who visit here: people who come for some advice on a new purchase, and people who can't seem to find a bed they like and have tried 3 or more mattresses.  If you believe you fall into the first category, then you will problaby not have many issues purchasing over the internet.  I would only purchase from internet company that has acceptable BBB rating and has been in business for several years (as evidenced by posts on this forum).  You shoudl inquire about the cost of actually returning a mattress as well as looking at comfort exchange policy and cost of shipping.

As for Talalay vs Dunlop, I was like you and read a lot of different opinions online.  After a while, it seemed to me that the quality of the latex mattered more than which process you purchased.  These mattress companies are simply resellers of someone's latex with a cover; asking where they source their latex should help you decide.

Perhaps you can do some creative googling to find some local companies that distribute latex, a la Foam By Mail so that you can purchase locally.

Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #9 Aug 13, 2011 11:09 AM
Joined: Jun 2, 2011
Points: 481
Iris wrote:

 


What are the main co's that use the good quality latex?     I originally thinking that total dunlop was the way to go, but now I'm wondering about that dunlop core and talalay top.   Sigh.  I know that with some of these products I can return pieces, but I'd really like to get it right the first time if possible.   Plus with mattress.net, it's a one time deal.....but I am wondering if the zipperless mattresses would wear better, or if the convenience of the zipper to exchange pieces would be more practical.   

Mike from LI said that Organic Mattress out of CA or Arizona Premium use their natural talalay.  

Did I mention I'm in Southern NJ?

I was pretty torn about getting 100% natural latex or not.  There is really a lot of debate about the matter.  Of course places that specialize in all natural / organic beds will say all natural latex is The way to go,    But, I did talk to Latex Intl like you did and I bought the story that the vast majority of their latex is blended.  I went with SleepEZ based on their reputation and policies and they recommended blended.  So we shall see. 

If there is any off-gassing from my mattress, I couldn't tell.  I don't smell a thing.  IIRC, the synthetic stuff is locked into the material during processing and other chemicals are washed off the foam with water. 

I have my receipt of purchase, and warranty card from SleepEZ.  If this thing totally breaks down, it shall be repaired/replaced according to their policy.

 

Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #10 Aug 20, 2011 1:38 AM
Joined: Aug 20, 2011
Points: 2
Is it me or did it seem like the Dunlop piece was more beat up to begin with, it was packed tighter and so on.
Re: Talalay Vs Dunlop?? (this mattress decision is making me crazy!)
Reply #11 Aug 20, 2011 6:23 PM
Sleep and rest!
Location: Fort Myers
Joined: Aug 20, 2011
Points: 14
Forget the Talalay dunlop analogy.

Go with the mattress that is more comfortable and less money.

Both methods of producing latex are different but the end result is nearly the same. Both are synthetic latex, and will last for years.

You will not sleep hot either.

Personally i do not like how latex feels, I call it the trampoline effect. Too bouncy for me, especially when placed on top of mattress springs.