What Topper over 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Sep 18, 2008 11:01 PM
Joined: Sep 18, 2008
Points: 2
My wife and I bought a 10" Memory Foam Mattress from Overstock.Com two weeks ago, and I'm finding it too soft for me.  I'm 6.4 and 220lbs and I find the 3 inches of 5lb Memory Foam is too soft and it feels like my pressure points on my back and sides sink in all the way to the 7 inch layer of foam on the bottom.  Some mornings I have some light lower back pain, and wish the mattress had a bit more support.  Is there anything I can do about this?  Overstock doesn't take mattress returns, so that's not an option. 

Would it make sense to buy a Topper, and if so I'd be grateful for recommendations.  Should I go with a latex topper on top of the memory foam?  And what thickness would work well?

Thanks.
Re: What Topper over 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Reply #1 Sep 18, 2008 11:29 PM
Joined: Aug 30, 2007
Points: 428
Hello Algreen - Unfortunately there is nothing you can add to the top of a mattress that lacks support that will improve the situation. You should sink through the comfort layer to some extent and feel the support layer underneath. If not your comfort layer is too thick or too firm. Your description makes it sounds as though the real culprit may be the lack of support from the foundation layer. Do you know all of the specs of your mattress? Note that I have long since stopped doing business with Overstock.com because they did not allow returns on anything, regardless of the reason.
This message was modified Sep 18, 2008 by kbell
Re: What Topper over 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Reply #2 Sep 18, 2008 11:50 PM
Joined: Sep 18, 2008
Points: 2
Kbell,

Overstock describes the mattress combination this way: "Incredible mattress features a 3-inch layer of 5-pound density Nasa developed memory foam on top of a 7-inch, 2.5-pound density supportive base layer of traditional foam"

What would happen if I put a 1" layer of firm latex between the 3" layer of memory foam and the base layer?  Would that add more support?
Re: What Topper over 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Reply #3 Sep 19, 2008 5:48 AM
Joined: Sep 7, 2007
Points: 476
kbell wrote:
Note that I have long since stopped doing business with Overstock.com because they did not allow returns on anything, regardless of the reason.

FYI: Overstock.com has since changed their return policy as follows:

Standard Return Policy

You can return most new and unopened items within 30 days of delivery for a full refund.* Items must be returned in new or unused condition and contain all original materials included with the shipment. All returned items will be inspected and awarded a partial refund if opened or used. If the return is a result of our error, the full cost of the merchandise and shipping charges will be refunded.

For items returned after 30 days, Overstock.com will grant a credit of up to 80% of the item’s

We do not give refunds for the following products:

  • Swimming Suits
  • Undergarments
  • Body Jewelry (i.e. all items within the "Body Jewelry" sub-category)
  • Factory-sealed sports collectible sets
  • Gift Cards
  • Club O Membership Fee
  • Perfumes and Fragrances
  • Ink Cartridges
  • Medical Items
  • Memory Foam Mattresses that have been opened or taken out of their plastic wrap
  • Toys for Tots purchases
  • Cigars, wines, and perishable products (food items, chocolates, plants & flowers & wholesale flowers)
  • Any CD, DVD, VHS tape, software, video game, and cassette tape that has been opened/taken out of its plastic wrap
  • Any specially-labeled designer apparel, handbags and accessories that have had the security tag removed
  • Case Packs/Bulk Items: No partial case pack returns will be accepted. Product must be returned in the original shipping pack with all individual items unopened
  • Other select items, as noted on the product description page

This is an example of why you should NEVER order something as personal as a mattress unless you have the option of returning it if it doesn't suit you.

Re: What Topper over 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Reply #4 Sep 19, 2008 6:01 AM
Joined: Sep 7, 2007
Points: 476
Algreen345 wrote:
Kbell,

Overstock describes the mattress combination this way: "Incredible mattress features a 3-inch layer of 5-pound density Nasa developed memory foam on top of a 7-inch, 2.5-pound density supportive base layer of traditional foam"

What would happen if I put a 1" layer of firm latex between the 3" layer of memory foam and the base layer?  Would that add more support?

Can you actually separate the layers? Most mattresses bond the two foams together. If you can separate the layers you might be better off putting some 44 ILD HR foam under the visco. You're a big guy and need something extra firm to give you more support. Overstock's description doesn't specify what ILD the base foam is. It might be 35--which is firm, just not firm enough for someone your weight. You could try this in 1" increments. If it's still too soft try adding another inch. Placing firmer foam under the visco will make the MF feel firmer too. But it doesn't work the other way. You have to place the support foam under the visco not over it.
Re: What Topper over 10" Memory Foam Mattress
Reply #5 Sep 19, 2008 11:48 AM
Joined: Aug 30, 2007
Points: 428
Algreen345 wrote:
Kbell,<BR><BR>Overstock describes the mattress combination this way: &quot;<span class="normal">Incredible mattress features a 3-inch layer of 5-pound density Nasa developed memory foam on top of a 7-inch, 2.5-pound density supportive base layer of traditional foam&quot;<BR><BR>What would happen if I put a 1&quot; layer of firm latex between the 3&quot; layer of memory foam and the base layer?  Would that add more support?<br type="_moz"/></span>

Algreen - If the problem is due to a lack of support provided by the foundation layer then I doubt your solution would work out in the long run. However I went to the Overstock.com website and read some of the bad reviews. You will see many good reviews although I did not see any that said they had the mattress for several months. Most of the people who left bad reviews felt the mattress was too firm (although not all did.) If the problem is that you're sinking through a comfort layer into a too firm foundation layer and that is what is creating the pressure points then an additional intermediate layer may solve the problem for you. From the review by bedanalyzer, "This top three inches are way squishier than I was expecting and the bottom way firmer."

The point of a third layer in a three layer foam mattress is exactly this; to make a smooth transition between the comfort layer to the foundation layer. The problem with this approach is that if the memory foam really is too soft then adding an intermediate layer may increase the chances of hammocking. One of the reviewers mentioned that the layers were bonded so you'll need to check that out. In the final analysis though if the foams used in this mattress are not high quality (which is fairly likely at this price point) then any attempt to fix the problem may be a bandaid solution. You could be throwing good money after bad.

Cloud9 - Thanks for straightening me out on Overstock's new return policy. For me it isn't long enough and I'll take my money elsewhere.